CONTACT

TRULY-LOCAL

29 PARADISE LANE

815-326-9061

John@Truly-Local.org

815-326-9061

info@truly-localllc.com

The transformation of America's rural communities landscape is occurring at an unprecedented pace, driven by a critical battle between local businesses and large corporate retailers. This struggle, often overlooked in national discourse, has far-reaching implications for the future of small-town America.

According to the Institute for Local Self-Reliance, between 2000 and 2015, over 40% of America's small businesses closed their doors permanently. This trend accelerated during the digital revolution, with e-commerce growing from 4.2% of total retail sales in 2010 to over 21% by 2023. These statistics represent more than mere numbers – they represent a fundamental shift in how local economies function.

The entry of big-box retailers follows a predictable pattern. Initially, these corporations often receive substantial tax incentives from local governments – averaging $1.2 million per store, according to Good Jobs First. This investment, while attractive in the short term, often yields diminishing returns. Studies show that for every $100 spent at a big-box retailer, only $14 remains in the local economy, compared to $48 when the same amount is spent at a local business.

The impact extends beyond retail economics. Research from the Economic Policy Institute demonstrates that when a Supercenter enters a community, it eliminates an average of 1.4 local jobs for every job it creates. Furthermore, these new jobs typically offer lower wages – about 15% less than the retail sector average – and fewer benefits, contributing to increased reliance on public assistance programs.

The proliferation of dollar stores presents another challenge. In rural areas, dollar store density has increased by 87% since 2001, with some communities seeing one store for every 3,000 residents. While these stores promise convenience and affordability, they often contribute to food deserts by deterring full-service grocery stores from entering the market, as documented by the Institute for Local Self-Reliance.

The fiscal impact on local governments is equally concerning. A study by Civic Economics found that online retail sales generate virtually no sales tax revenue for local governments, while big-box retailers generate approximately 50% less tax revenue per square foot compared to independent local business districts. This reduction in revenue directly affects essential services – from road maintenance to emergency response times.

Media independence also suffers. Since 2004, approximately 2,100 local newspapers have closed, creating "news deserts" in many rural communities. This decline correlates strongly with the erosion of local advertising revenue, which has shifted to national chains and digital platforms.

However, communities can fight back through strategic action:  Many communities have implemented "local first" purchasing policies, requiring government agencies to prioritize local vendors. Such policies typically generate a 10-30% premium in local economic activity.  Communities that invest in downtown revitalization see an average 15% increase in property values within three years, according to the National Main Street Center. Historic preservation districts typically generate 13% more value per square foot than surrounding areas.  Instead of offering incentives to outside corporations, communities can invest in local entrepreneurship. Programs like Michigan's Economic Gardening initiative have shown that every $1 invested in local business development generates $2.77 in economic activity.

Successful "buy local" campaigns typically increase local business revenue by 7-8% annually, compared to communities without such programs.  Communities that successfully develop and market their unique characteristics see 20-30% higher tourism revenue and increased business retention rates.

The solution lies in understanding that economic development isn't just about lower prices – it's about creating sustainable local economies. When communities maintain their economic independence, they retain control over their future. Data shows that communities with higher percentages of locally owned businesses have 15% higher per capita income growth, 50% higher civic engagement, and 40% higher charitable giving

The future of rural communities hinges on recognizing this struggle and taking decisive action. As Jane Jacobs noted in "The Death and Life of Great American Cities," the most successful communities are those that maintain their economic diversity and local character. By understanding the data behind these economic trends and implementing strategic solutions, communities protect their economic sovereignty while building resilient local economies for future generations.

The choice between Main Street and Wall Street isn't just about where we shop – it's about who we want to be as communities and what legacy we wish to leave for future generations.

John Newby is a nationally recognized Columnist, Speaker, & Publisher. He consults with Chambers, Communities, Business & Media. His “Building Main Street, not Wall Street,” column appears in 60+ newspapers and media outlets. As founder of Truly-Local, he assists chambers, communities, media, and businesses in creating synergies that build vibrant communities. He can be reached at: John@Truly-Local.org.